想更好地了解 RI 和 NUS High,请大家给些信息。

明年PSLE。 我只是希望找个更适合孩子的学校。想更多的了解 RI 与 NUS High.(注: 先不管分数。)

请有孩子在RI 或者NUS High 的家长给些孩子在学校的情况或他们的看法。先谢谢了!

请先 登录 后评论

39 个回答

孔瑶盛

不同的是RI没有女生

请先 登录 后评论
蒋震

可以去RGS啊,全部是女生

我家的是小子。

请先 登录 后评论
谢璐

建议静雯多联系RI办公室,我从来不象你这样跟这网上听意见,浪费时间

请先 登录 后评论
谢言晨

一些国大附中和莱佛士不一样的地方:

在国大附中第五年需要住宿舍一整年。第五、六年可同时修读物理、化学和生物,不必选一科contrasting subject。RI理科生只能从三科科学中选读二科。

NUS High 学生在报读NUS modules没有限制,不像其它初院最多只能报读两个H3 NUS modules.

请先 登录 后评论
翟霞

nus high 在管理上给学生自由更多一些,老师学生之间更平等,但是同时对于孩子既是好事也是坏事,家长需要多督促,课程设置上比较自由些,但是在校内空闲时间比较多,因为课程表安排和cca 安排要考虑整个6个年级的所有学生的时间,所以有很多空闲时间在学校,经常是拜一或者拜五有3-4小时空闲时间,所以这个时间上有些浪费。

教课进度快,但是由于学生年龄小,所以深度并不是很够(指中一中二的学生),但是深度还是远超ri 普通班,但是ri 天才班 还有奥赛班的进度和难度和nus high 不差上下,甚至ri 略胜一筹。 nus high 功课并不多,学校也比较重视数理, 英文教学远远不如ri, 华文教学还不错,教的都是有用的和o水准考试相关的,不会给喜欢数理的孩子增加华文学习的负担,但是英文教学确实不够,英文老师们也大多不太负责任,请假不来上课的情况经常出现( 仅英文一个科目), 数学物理化学生物这四个教研组的老师非常认真负责,学生有任何疑问都可以找任何一位老师请教沟通,不一定是自己的任课老师,办公室任何一位老师都有责任也会热情地回答每个孩子地问题。

在竞赛上,nus high 三年级上学期开设化学竞赛班,大概10多人, 是老师推荐的,如果老师未推荐,自己一定要跟老师争取,通常老师对于积极的孩子都会给予机会和肯定,下学期开设物理竞赛课,自己任意报名,数学竞赛一年级开始就有了,这些所有的竞赛班也对1,2年级的学生开放,但是要通过一定的测试方可去参加培训。化学竞赛班的内容教的比较超前,但是难度不是特别高,物理竞赛教得很慢,但是很扎实和细致,难度也是相当大,通常在物理竞赛班考试不及格甚至0分的情况是很正常的。学校对于实验的培训非常扎实,普遍学生实验能力很强,但由于学校给太多自由给学生,所以在题海战术上放的力气不够,训练题目太少,学校只是在引导和启发,剩下的都需要家长和孩子课后在家里下功夫。在nus  high 任何比赛和培训家长一定要多了解,然后及时和学校老师沟通,这样孩子才能多些机会。

部分cca 一周培训两次,部分一周一次,cca上占用时间不是很多,这一点比较合理。学校给学生cca的压力不大,只要学生积极参与比赛,学校都是鼓励的态度,不用要求学生一定拿什么名次和奖项。

大概就这样,想起来我再补充。这些都是我个人意见,欢迎讨论。

点评

4justice

典型的重理轻文,呵呵。。 

详情

回复

请先 登录 后评论
向旭芝

nus high 在管理上给学生自由更多一些,老师学生之间更平等,但是同时对于孩子既是好事也是坏事,家长需要 ...

谢谢你。真的很具体!

请先 登录 后评论
濮阳朗

请教前辈,听说RI是采取比较放任的教学方式,考试少,老师也不太管,和华中的考试多多,老师盯得紧,是截 ...

   我也有同样的担心。

请先 登录 后评论
申冠

非常同意。

有竞争才有动力。与强手竞争,不成虎,也成狼。

讲句不谦虚的话,

我不觉得新加坡还有那间学校可以和RI比教师、管理、课程设置、CCA、教学资源等方面的。

请先 登录 后评论
姜英冰

你家孩子是明年PSLE对吧? 偶这个马甲被你呼唤进来了,顺便贴点东西:

Good news for all the NUSH kids on Public transport. Come 8 Oct when Circle Line is fully running, Kent Ridge is the nearest MRT Stn, barely 3 minutes bus ride ( only 2 stops) on the express AYE. From back gate take bus 97, 197, 963 at Bus stop 17129 (after NUSH school) to kent Ridge MRT. Opp Bus stop (17121 , Blik 610) is the stop to alight when you take the bus from kent bridge NUH bus stop after coming out of MRT Stn.

**********************************************************************

For those joining in y1, percentage contributing to GPA of 5 are y1 (10%) Y2 (10%) y3 (20%) y4 (20%) y5 (20%) y6 (20%).

For those joining y3, it is y3 (25%) y4 (25%) y5 (25%) y6 (25%)

Hence NUSH emphasise consistent performance throughout the 6 years and not a single exam situation like "A" level.

这个我自己还没有去NUSH的网站再次查询证实过

**********************************************************************

COP for the PSLE phase for Y1 admission for

2005 (admission year 2006) -> Lowest PSLE T-score: 237 and highest PSLE-T-score: 273

2006 (admission year 2007) ->Lowest PSLE T-score: 259 and highest PSLE-T-score: 273

2007 (admission year 2008) ->Lowest PSLE T-score: 262 and highest PSLE-T-score: 277

2010 (admission year 2011) ->Lowest PSLE T-score: 264

**********************************************************************

Name of Scholar Year of Award Scholarship Awarded Secondary School / Junior College Attended Course of Study Country

Kylie Goh Jin Ying 2011 Singapore Government Scholarship (Open) NUS High School of Mathematics & Science Biology United States of America Stanford University

Jessica Loo Li Ping 2011 Singapore Government Scholarship (Open) NUS High School of Mathematics & Science Economics United Kingdom University College London

Chew Xizhi Stephanie 2011 Singapore Government Scholarship (Open) NUS High School of Mathematics & Science Law United Kingdom University College London

**********************************************************************

Yes confirm is 10 succesfully got in Medicine out of 220+ for last year graduated batch!! They already went for their matriculation and finally 8 stay in the course with 1 went to Hong Kong Uni to read Medicine and 1 chose to read Dentistry.

This is really an impressive number! Understand that those got in are not really the top top ones. But I believe there will be more admitted to Medicine in the coming years!

I happen to "kaypo" at this year open house talk where Dr Hang was saying that Queens University (where ? , Australia ) has no "quota" on NUSH student intake for Medicine studies b'cos our student are really that good.

Yes total from Year 1 intake plus Year 3 intake make up to 220+ last year.

As for University of Queensland (if I am not wrong), I also heard the same news and DD is also strong asked to join for next year attachment programmes for Year 6 students for a period of a few months!

The University is very impressed with NUS High acceralted programmes that they see a very bright future in the students and are willingly to take in the students as long as they meet their criteria.

As NUS High students, we feel beholden to clarify certain misconceptions which have cropped up here.

**********************************************************************

The standard of English in NUS High is reflective of the standard of Singaporean English amongst the student population in the country in general. True, there may be less appreciation for the subject in the cohort, compared to enthusiasm for other academic subjects. However, you’ll find that our showing on this front is comparable to other top schools nationally. Some have mentioned presentations at the Pre-University Seminar; you will find that for all the years we have participated, teachers and other observers responded favourably towards the quality of our presentations.

In addition, NUS High students have won numerous accolades in speaking and writing. From the original Gavel Club members (Class of 2008) up to now, NUS High has acquitted itself well in public speaking competitions, including Champion in the YMCA Plain English Speaking Awards, and the Gavel Club, which includes the debate society, remains active on the local oratorical scene. Moreover, NUS High regularly obtains awards in the Royal Commonwealth Society Commonwealth Essay Writing Contest, including first place globally in 2009. Locally, we have had champions and award-winners in the Stanford University-NJC Creative Writing Competition and the A*Star Institute of High Performance Computing Science Chronicles fiction competition. NUS High students have also published work in magazines from smaller places like 14:59, to the Quarterly Literary Review Singapore and Ceriph magazine. At the Straits Times School Newspapers Competition, we have obtained the Best Writing award two years running, and also came in second last year. A quick check with NUS High productions such as Journal Watermark (http://journalwatermark.wordpress.com) and the College Talk blog (http://nushscollegetalk.posterous.com) should further dispel any doubts as to the capacity of NUS High students and graduates.

Another correction: the graduating class of 2010, which comprised the original 2005 Year 1 cohort and the 2007 Year 3 cohort, was 177 students. This year, the Class of 2011 has produced 209 graduands.

**********************************************************************

QUESTION FOR NUSH STUDENTS/PARENTS...

Would you say that NUS High School is a way out of the overly structured Singapore education system in the following ways?

- Students are less likely to require private tuition compared to their counterparts taking GCE exams

- There is more scope for independent thinking and creativity

- Teaching staff are more open to unconventional approaches to problem solving

Fully agreed with points made by DVL. I have a GEPer DD in NUSH Year 1 (barely 7 month only) and a DD in a top mainstream school Sec 3 doing triple science. So I can do some comparison ...

For the same topics in physics eg Kinematics NUSH curriculum covered in real depth and scope for the foundation level 1. That kind of stuff remember I did in "A" level physics. Same for Chemistry topics, they are covering 'A" level depth and details. In Biology they have done a module called Ecology and thermal energy transfer (never done this 'O' or "A" level ) and now on Microbiology. Same as Maths curriculum, my NUSH year 1 DD is already doing what her sister has barely started in sec 3. By end of year 2 foundation , she would have covered more than ‘O” level syllabus. At end of year 4 Advance she would have covered beyond “A” levels and U syllabus. NUSH course is structured as 2 year foundation, 2 year Advance and 2 year Specialisation. By year 5 and graduating year 6, they are already doing individual research areas in Maths and Science at U level.

Such is the accelerated programme in both Maths and Science programme that it is not a place for average learners who need tuition. I think the DSA testing and DSA Camp would have weed out those who need extra "coaching".

NUSH kids are expected to be fast thinkers and self-learners. They must have the passion and expected to be fast learners. Some of them already are way ahead of their peer in Maths syllabus. One year1 kid had a diagnostic Maths “testing” and was “promoted” to Year 5 maths programme.

Looking at her sister's Biology, Physics and Chemistry lesson depth in coverage, My triple Science mainstream Sec 3 DD eye see star at the my year 1 DD work.

As a matter of fact, most of them (taking science-related or mathematics) are already one-foot in NUS or NTU b'cos of their advanced research programme. Of course there are some chose to go business or law. Most of them graduated with NUSH Dip with major honours with High distinction and distinction.

Not mentioning recognition by major IVY league and OxBridge , a Diploma with merit is an almost a gurantee place in any of 4 local u. So much for competing with the "A" level. That's the reason why I had no qualm in advising my DD to chose NUSH above RGS where most of her GEP classmates went to. Her GEP classmate top in RGPS 2010 PSLE is also in NUSH and not RGS for a change. I think more girls will join this year.

My DD is in NUSH year 1. Based on her feedback last year (if I remember correctly) , DSA assessment is clearly on two aspects - individual work and performance during the group interaction.

At the various rotated stations (Physics, Chemistry and Biology etc) the students will be exposed to experiments and set-up.There will be some hands on, as of all experiment observations are made, etc. Instructions are all clear stated. Certain theory and concept may be explained, and for individual assessment, the students will tested on how well they understood all these as they are required to apply or make inference to answer some of the question. I think a high percentage of marks go into the individual assessment components.

Within the group, assessments are made on the individual knowledge cum problem solving skills within the group environment. They are also assessed on the "leadership" and co-operative behaviour in group problem solving environment. In a way the kids really have to prove their “worth” within the few hours. So you can expect certain amount of "friendly" competitions among the kids as they try to out do or out spoke each other.

The few teachers/ assessors and observers will be able to differentiate the good one (invariably the quiet one) from those "noise" maker or those attention seekers and those who hodge limelight. Marks will be awarded to each participants.

For the English section, the students are also assessed on their communication skill, their maturity of thought as they are required to express their views in writing essay on certain topic.

A couple more days to the DSA camp and I believe most of you out there are getting excited/anxious.

**********************************************************************

This is my 1st post and a little sharing as a parent of NUSHians.

I believe this camp serves to suss out the right type of personality for the unique school environment so it is not necessary to do any kind of studying/preparation.

From my observation, kids who are good team-players and independent thrives in the environment. Team spirit required for the vast numbers/types of group-based projects and independence for the beyond classroom quest for knowledge.

Just to reveal a little known fact, there are a few extremely talented kids in this school who exhibits some autistic characteristics. So if you do meet a kid who does not respond to your questions or runs away from you, do not be alarm, you could have just met a Einstein/Newton-to-be.  

**********************************************************************

Key concerns about NUSH is always (1) is it too early to decide on the kids' choice of career and (2) the acceptance level of NUSH diploma.

Without doubt, NUSH mission is to produce future researchers, mathematicians, scientists, engineers, doctors etc. but that does not mean that it would neglect humanities. After all, how good a scientist can you be if you do not have the human touch? The school does offer humanities subjects and from Year 1- 4, it is compulsory to study a humanity subject. Year 1 & 2 will do Integrated Humanity and by Year 3-4, kids will have to choose a humanity subject, be it History, Geography, Economics, Art, Music. I understand that in most IP and mainstream schools, all the brighter kids will compete to do 3 sciences + 1 Humanity. So there is no difference except that in NUSH, you do not need to fight to do Triple Science. By Year 5-6, one can still choose a Humanity subject if one wishes to. Again, not much difference from the common A Level combi of 1 math, 2 science + 1 contrasting subject. Key difference at for NUSH Year 5-6, it is not compulsory to do a contrasting subject. 3 batches had graduated from NUSH and I understand some (not many though) had gone on to pursue non Maths or science related courses at Uni. A few had chosen to read economics and I believe there is one who had gone to read law. Emphasis is definitely on Maths & Science, but it does not stop one from pursuing other courses. NUS is rated highly in the academic world, with the support from NUS, there is no reason for universities around the world not to recognise NUSH diploma. In fact, many past NUSH graduates secured their place in some top universities even before they finish their final exams. It says alot when some top IP schools like RI & HCI, are awarding their own diplomas, on top of the A Level.

It is not my intention to confuse you. I just to want to provide more info for you to make an informed decision.

For this year 2011 intake, 7 ex-RGPS , 5 GEP including the top RGPS girl + 2 mainstream.

NUSH wants to groom the very best of maths and science students to emerge as leaders in their scientific fields. That may be through research, academia, engineering innovations etc. The school is modeled after the Bronx School of Science in New York which produced numerous Nobel laureates.

http://www.kiasuparents.com/kiasu/forum/viewtopic.php?f=39&t=2309&start=980

点评

静雯

改朝换代了。明年PSLE 要让贤了。 

详情

回复

发表于 22-9-2011 14:44

jjrchome

楼主貌似很年轻,不会有这么大的孩子。。。 

详情

回复

发表于 22-9-2011 13:34

jjrchome

哈哈,有几次我也写过"明年PSLE。。”,后来越看越别扭,才想起来这是个人名。。。 

详情

回复

请先 登录 后评论
陆爱

以上是我收集的资料,未经官方证实。

谢谢了。这么多信息,我要慢慢消化了。

在网上得知你儿子选择了NUS High. 有没有在RI和NUS High之间举棋不定过?

请先 登录 后评论