请问paper被接受了,但是reviewer还有comments怎么办?
如果请问paper已经被接受了,email如下:
Editor: I am pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been accepted for publication, provided that you address all reviewers' comments (if any) in the final manuscript.
Associate editor: accept as is.
reviewer #1: (还有一些comments, 和问题)
这个reviewer的comments 我在final manuscript里面没法做相应的改动. 如果像revise paper一样,当然可以在paper后面加response to reviewers' comments, 但是final manuscript就不能了。如果不对其一一回应,会不会不让发表啊? 我又听说如果accept了,final manuscript就不会再给reviewer看;再加上associate editor说"accept as is", 就是说不用改了,而editor的是"address all reviewers' comments"
请教高人这种情况怎么办? 谢谢!
章国
叫你老板处理啊
(你不会是老板吧?)为什么不能做改动呢? 如果他的评论是对的,你就要改啊。如果不对你就附上证据反驳啊(不一定要写在文章里,回信给editor就好了。)如果问的问题很重要你也可以把回应放在文章的references里。