请问@南洋暴雪 这样犯法么?

假如我看到联合早报的一条新闻,我想转到华新上来。
根据联合早报母公司SPH的T&C, http://sph.com.sg/legal/website_tnc.html
以下关键段落:
4. Content Use Conditions 4.1 You may not reproduce, modify, adapt, translate, publish, display, communicate, transmit, broadcast, podcast, webcast, distribute, sell, trade or exploit for any commercial or other purposes, any portion of, or any access to:   4.1.1 any Service; 4.1.2 the Site; 4.1.3 any SPH Content except, to the extent permitted, with the prior written consent of SPH or unless expressly permitted in these Website Conditions; or 4.1.4 any Third Party User Content except, to the extent permitted, with the prior written consent of SPH and the owner or licensee of the specific User Content. 4.2 Without prejudice to the generality of Clause 4.1, you agree not to reproduce, display or otherwise provide access to the Services, SPH Content, or Third Party User Content on another website or server, for example through framing, mirroring, linking, spidering, scraping or any other technological means (including any technology available in the future), without the prior written permission of SPH.  4.3 You may for your personal, non-commercial use:   4.3.1 retrieve and display SPH Content on any compatible device owned by you; 4.3.2 print a single copy of SPH Content on paper (but not photocopy them); and 4.3.3 store such SPH Content in electronic form on disk or on a mobile device owned by you (but not on any server or other storage device connected to a network). 4.4 All SPH Content are the copyrighted work of SPH or its content or software providers, and SPH reserves and retains all rights in the SPH Content.  Use of some SPH Content may be governed by the terms of an accompanying end user license agreement.  4.5 You may not decompile, reverse engineer or otherwise attempt to discover the source code of any SPH Content available on the Site or through a Service except under the specific circumstances expressly permitted by law or SPH in writing
 
请问我在这种情况下把这条新闻转到华新上来:
1. 如果SPH想追究,会有被起诉的风险么?
 
另外,如果华新要求用户发的信息必须符合法规,如果任何内容的纠纷用户本身要承担责任,
2. 这种情况下,华新会被追究什么责任么?
 
谢谢花时间读贴,如果能发几个链接来作为参考看看会不胜感激。
 
请先 登录 后评论

7 个回答

宁云

不至于被起诉吧,但可能会被要求删除
xmlzj

请先 登录 后评论
怀磊

各位中介经常把联合早班的中文新闻发到自己的微博上做长微博图片
这么说也是违法的么?

请先 登录 后评论
怀磊

联合早报
中文新闻是要收费订阅的

请先 登录 后评论
宁云

我不是律师,但是新闻是卖钱的,未经许可转载貌似会侵犯知识产权哟
这就跟下载电影差不多吧,明明违法,但拦不住大家下载。

请先 登录 后评论
欧阳淑蓉

这是关于版权法的问题
如果是别人自己i写的, 你直接拿来复制肯定是侵犯别人作品复制权。但是针对你的行为,你很可能有一个fair comment的抗辩。
假设你的抗辩不成立,那么华新作为CP,有义务在对方要求时进行删除。
但是违法基本上都是个民法行为,这种程度的行为不会入刑的。

请先 登录 后评论
怀磊

谢谢回复。个人方面很清楚了。
假如个别用户有侵权行为把SPH旗下的网站/报纸的内容贴华新上来。
SPH要追究的话也是去追究那个用户,而不是华新。
如果他们要求华新把内容删掉,华新是有义务配合的。
但是华新不会被追究更多的责任。

可以这么理解么?

请先 登录 后评论
欧阳淑蓉

这个我暂时不知道,给我点时间查下
最近有点忙

请先 登录 后评论
  • 0 关注
  • 0 收藏,313 浏览
  • 怀磊 提出于 2019-07-18 10:10